West Beset by Moral Contradictions

• Freedom of speech never guarantees there won’t be some repercussions

• Why can Prophet Muhammad be defamed but Holocaust remains taboo?

By Patrick J. Buchanan —

Western media are declaring the million-man march in Paris, where world leaders paraded down Boulevard Voltaire in solidarity with France, a victory over terrorism. Isn’t it pretty to think so? Unfortunately, the massacre at the French magazine Charlie Hebdo, its military-style execution, the escape of the assassins and their blazing end in a shootout on January 9 was a triumph of terrorism not seen since 9-11.

Unlike the Boston Marathon bombing where the Tsarnaevs did not know or care whom they maimed or killed, the attack on Charlie Hebdo by the Kouachi brothers was purposeful and targeted terrorism.

And like a flash of lightning in the dark, it exposed the moral contradictions and confusion of the Western world.

During the slaughter the Kouachis shouted “Allahu akbar,” said they had “avenged the Prophet” and spoke of ties to al Qaeda.

And the first response of President Francois Hollande? These terrorists “have nothing to do with the Muslim religion.”

This is political correctness of a rare order. Perhaps terminal.

Linking arms with Hollande in solidarity and unity on January 11 was Israeli Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu who declared, “I wish to tell to all French and European Jews—Israel is your home.” Colleagues urged French Jews to flee to Israel.

Marching on the other side of Hollande was Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas who seeks to have Netanyahu’s Israel indicted in the International Criminal Court for war crimes in Gaza.

You call that solidarity?


In chanting “Je suis Charlie,” the marchers showed support for a magazine French Muslims rightly believe is racist and anti-Islamic.

Yet, Marine Le Pen, leading in the polls for the French presidency, was blacklisted from marching for remarks about Muslim immigration that are benign compared to what Charlie Hebdo regularly publishes.

All weekend long, journalists called it an imperative for us all to defend the lewd and lurid blasphemies of the satirical magazine.

But as journalist Christopher Dickey points out, Muslims in the suburbs of Paris wonder why insulting the prophet is a protected freedom in France, while denying the Holocaust can get you a prison term. Hypocrisy is indeed the tribute that vice pays to virtue.

Moreover, all this chatter about freedom of speech and of the press misses the point. It was not the right to publish that provoked the slaughter, but the content of what was published.

When Aaron Burr challenged Alexander Hamilton to a duel and killed him, he was not attacking the First Amendment freedom of the press, but rather Hamilton, for defamation of Burr’s character, which had helped to destroy Burr’s career.

What the commentators seem to be saying about the assault on Charlie Hebdo is that not only is what is spoken or published protected by the First Amendment, but those who print and publish vile things must never suffer violent consequences.

People who believe this is attainable are living in a dreamworld and may not be long for this one. Even as children you knew there were words you did not use about someone else’s girlfriend, mother, family, faith or race if you did not want a thrashing.

That same day millions marched in France, Saudi Arabia was administering 50 lashes to Internet “blogger” Raif Badawi, who had been convicted of insulting Saudi clergy, the first of 1,000 lashes over 20 weeks in addition to his 10-year jail sentence. Had Badawi been guilty of apostasy, he would have been executed.

Welcome to the new Middle East, same as the old Middle East.

And Islam and the prophet were not the only targets of Charlie Hebdo. Catholicism was, also. In one cartoon, Charlie Hebdo depicts the first and second persons of the blessed trinity in incestuous activity.

And we all are supposed to march in solidarity with that?

A liberal secular West might find this a democratic duty. Not all will. When people are using the First Amendment to assault the somewhat older Second Commandment, “Though shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain,” they should not be surprised when devout followers of Abrahamic faiths take a pass.

These Islamic terrorists are sending us a message: In the post-Christian West, Christians may turn the other cheek at insults to their God and faith. But Muslims are not turn-the-other cheek people. Insult our faith, mock the prophet and we will kill you.

An awakening and rising Islamic world—a more militant faith than Christianity or secularism—is saying to the West: We want you out of our part of the world, we are coming to your part of the world and you cannot stop us.

The Kouachi brothers sent yet another message. If you are a young Muslim willing to fight and die for Islam, do not waste your life as some suicide bomber in the wilds of Syria or Iraq. Do as we did: Shock and awe your enemies right inside the belly of the beast.

Donate to us

Patrick J. Buchanan is a writer, political commentator and presidential candidate and the author of the new book THE GREATEST COMEBACK: How Richard Nixon Rose From Defeat to Create the New Majority.

2 Comments on West Beset by Moral Contradictions

  1. Harold, in his position it’s hard to claim a false flag without evidence. I’m thinking it could have been Israel/CIA/French intelligence operation (or, even a staged event), but I have only indirect evidence for that.
  2. Pat doesn’t see a false flag here? Shocking isn’t it.

    Did you all see that story about a guy who worked at Charlie? It’s a photo of a guy with a caption above that reads:

    “I’m not Charlie…I’m Sine. I used to work for Charlie as a cartoonist. In 2009 I created a caricature showing Sarkozy’s son converting to Judaism for financial reasons. Charlie asked me to apologize and I refused. Charlie fired me for ridiculing Judaism!”

    Maurice Sinet, fired 2009 after 20 years as a cartoonist for Charlie Hebdo, due to his anti-Semitism.

    Anyway Pat, your story is better off in the MSM where this drivel belongs. Now run and play with the other sellouts, old man.

Comments are closed.